Total Knee Replacement

Psa 30:2 “I cried to you for help, O LORD my God, and you healed me;”

About Carl C. Eierle, MD

HIGHEST RECOMMENDATION

Good Hands Award 1.1

My Background

With over thirty-five years as a Sears Manager, fifteen years as an electronics company owner, five years as a Biomedical Manager at University Hospital, and now serving as senior minister of Servant of Christ Ministries, I have extensive experience evaluating individual performance. In retrospect, I have written only three other recommendation letters—always reserving them for those who far exceeded expectations, as verified with others. Carl C. Eierle, MD, is the fourth person I confidently recommend for total knee replacement surgery, also known as knee arthroplasty.

My Story

I have suffered from knee pain since college football.  In the past, shots and therapy were prescribed until early 2020, when the diagnosis revealed bone-on-bone with extreme arthritis in both knees. However, after the diagnosis, my attending physician still prescribed more shots and treatment, which, after years, almost had me bedridden.    After the subscribed treatment had ended, the next appointment to see my attending physician was more than six months away.  Frustrated and in pain, I made the appointment and started to wait.  By that time, my left knee was so bad that I almost called 911.   In conversations with one of my old college friends, he informed me that he just had his left knee replaced by Carl C. Eierle, MD, and highly recommended him.  I made an appointment, and in a month, surgery was scheduled.  No shots, no therapy, finally a possible cure to my everlasting pain, for the x-rays indicated that shots or treatment would not be effective under my knee condition.  FOR THE FIRST TIME, I FELT LIKE A PHYSICIAN WAS TREATING ME AS A PATIENT, RATHER THAN A COMMODITY.  November 12, 2024, was the scheduled date for the replacement of my left knee.  From the moment I entered HCA Florida Westside Hospital for my knee replacement surgery, all the staff, including every nurse and therapist, spoke highly of Dr. Eierle, informing me that he consistently delivers the very best results for each of his patients.  Well, they were telling the truth, because after surgery for the first time, my knee pain was gone.  Yes, I had severe pain from the surgery, but the throbbing Knee pain was gone.  Just weeks into therapy, the walker and cane were retired.
One Done One More

One Done, One More

Receiving the scheduled therapy, I found that my left knee was responding far better than I could have ever hoped for, but the therapy and exercises were making the right knee worse.  As I had initially scheduled to have my right knee replacement in a couple of years, I found that the right knee needed to be replaced far sooner.  On July 11, 2025, at Florida Medical Center, I had Carl C. Eierle, MD, perform a total knee replacement of my right knee. So, within 8 months, I had total knee replacement performed on both my knees. However, since previous therapy and exercise sessions had strengthened my right knee, I was able to walk on the first day without the use of a walker or cane.  And again, just like the staff, nurses, and therapists at HCA Florida Westside Hospital, they spoke highly of Dr. Eierle, repeatedly informing me that his patients achieve the best results.  Never in all my years have I heard from multiple staff members from different locations talk so highly of a doctor.  As you can now see, my recommendation is based on my personal experience, as well as conversations with my college friend and staff members from those two hospitals.
After Surgery Pain

My Personal Thoughts


Therapy
What I believe you will find is that extensive therapy and exercise before undergoing total knee replacement will result in the fastest recovery with the least pain.  I found in my case that my right knee replacement recovery time was far less than the left due to the therapy and exercise I received after surgery for the left total knee replacement.

Pain Management
I have spoken to numerous individuals and read countless posts on the topic of pain after total knee replacement.  What I can tell you is that everyone’s experience will be different.  Expect between 3 and 15 weeks of pain after surgery.  The good news is that the pain will gradually decrease over time. I am confident that Dr. Eierle will provide you with a subscription for pain management, therapy, and a CPM machine as he did for me.   If your pain persists after 15 weeks, it is most likely coming from various other issues that can only be alleviated with time, exercise, and possibly a TENS/EMG muscle stimulator.  However, following Carl C. Eierle, MD’s instructions will yield the best outcome.
Blue FAQ icon

Here are the pros and cons of total knee replacement

Should I avoid knee replacement?

Knee replacement isn’t a first-line treatment. It’s a good solution for individuals who are no longer able to control their symptoms with other methods. Before you consider knee replacement surgery, you should try conservative treatments like physical therapy and anti-inflammatory drugs.

 

What is the best age to have a knee replacement?

Most people who get a knee replacement are between the ages of 60 and 80 years old. Younger patients face an increased risk of wearing out the prosthetic and needing additional surgery. On the other hand, older patients tend to recover more slowly, so waiting too long can be a problem. Some studies recommend the early 70s as an optimal time to get the benefits of the operation with minimal risk of needing a second, revisional surgery later.

 

What happens if you wait too long for knee replacement?
Waiting too long for a knee replacement can cause your knees to deteriorate further, leading to more pain and further limiting your activity and mobility.

Additionally, as you age, surgery becomes riskier, and recovery takes longer. Delaying your operation too long can increase the risk of complications and make it harder to return to normal activities after the operation.

 

Are you ever the same after a knee replacement?

A knee replacement can give you a lot of independence and improve your quality of life, but it won’t be the same as having a healthy knee in good condition. You’ll need to be cautious about participating in high-impact sports and may still experience knee pain even after your knee replacement.
My college friend at 75 had total knee replacement performed on his left knee by Dr. Eierle, and months later, continued to play competitive handball.  Again, it was his recommendation and outcome that led me to make an appointment with him.

 

How many years does a knee replacement last?
Modern knee replacements last a long time. Studies show that 98% of patients still have the implant working 20 years after the operation.
600 S. Pine Island Road Plantation FL

Carl C. Eierle, MD
Orthopaedic Center of South Florida
600 S. Pine Island Road
Suite #300
Plantation, FL 33324
(954) 473-6344

I believe the doctor serves the tri-county area of South Florida, Dade, Broward, and West Palm Beach.  But, as in my case, I had to drive three hours to his office.  But, because of the ‘best results” received on my first total knee replacement, driving again three hours each way was not even a question.
About Carl C. Eierle, MD

Without any Doubt

I am pleased to present my “Good Hands” Award to Carl C. Eierle, MD, for total knee replacement. I hope my story and information are beneficial to you. Additionally, please note that the opinions I have listed above are my personal views, and that Carl C. Eierle, MD, has neither solicited nor been aware of my recommendation. My taking the time to write this recommendation is a gesture of my gratitude for achieving the “Best Results” on my total knee replacements. I pray for God’s guidance as you make your decision.